This object is in archive! 

scenes often fail to execute

Alexander Casassovici shared this problem 9 years ago
Known

Hi,


I have this scene "leaving house" that basically shuts down all the actuators (~20) in the house.

I have bound it to a button of a kfob-modded into a switch at the main door


On average I need to press 3 times the button for all the lights to shut down. every press does shut down some light but not all


can you ruggedise this please ?

Replies (4)

photo
1

Just make a rule...work much better. Also added some delay if you use 433MHZ modules.

photo
1

so I can hit all the zwave at once but add a small delay between 433 ?

how much delay do you use ?

photo
1

I dont use delay and it works for me 99% of the time. Have about 10-12, 433 lamps

photo
1

The 99% is the problem. Z-wave, because of it 2-way protocol, is a reliable protocol. So the Zipabox can always check the state of the Z-wave device. 433 Mhz protocol is a 1-way protocol. For that reaseon the box never can check the state of the device. So if for some reason the command is not received bij a device (i.e. collision with another 433 device) the box simply does not send the command again.

HeroS is right bind the Z-wave devices. No problem what so ever. Then create a rule in which you switch off the 433 devices. Problem devices can be switched of twice or three times. Don't forget to set the state on ON of such device and then switch off again.

Leave a Comment
 
Attach a file